PENIS PALS (Full Interview with Paige DeSorbo)

TL;DR

  • Father Cooper and Paige DeSorbo discover they dated the same person and have overlapping relationship histories that create unexpected drama
  • One of Paige's matches on a dating app was already in a relationship with Cooper's ex, revealing messy dating app scenarios
  • Paige and Cooper both dated the same famous NYC actor at the exact same time, going on identical dates
  • Paige discusses her transition into newly single life and the differences between dating younger versus older men
  • The conversation covers Paige's experiences with model apartment living in NYC, her all-girls school background, and navigating toxic female friendships
  • Paige opens up about her bad boy phase, being in love only once, and the realities of dating culture in New York City

Key Moments

0:00

Meeting Through An Ex and Dating App Drama

15:00

Discovering They Dated The Same Famous NYC Actor

28:00

Paige's Transition To Newly Single Life

42:00

Dating Younger vs Older Men Discussion

58:00

All-Girls School, Female Friendships, and Being In Love Once

Episode Recap

In this entertaining episode, Father Cooper sits down with NYC reality TV star and fashion blogger Paige DeSorbo for a candid conversation that unfolds like gossiping with close friends. The episode kicks off with an explosive revelation about their overlapping romantic histories. The two discovered they knew each other through an ex-boyfriend, but the drama escalates when they learn that one of Paige's dating app matches was already in a relationship with Cooper's ex. This kind of digital dating overlap becomes the launching point for deeper discussions about modern relationship dynamics and how small the dating world can feel in a major city like New York. The conversation takes an even wilder turn when they reveal they were both dating the same famous actor in NYC simultaneously, even going on the same exact dates with him. This shocking coincidence becomes the perfect catalyst for exploring the chaos of New York City dating culture and how easily people's timelines can intersect without their knowledge. Beyond the dramatic revelations, Paige opens up about her current life as a newly single woman navigating the dating scene with fresh eyes. She discusses the pros and cons of dating younger men versus older men, sharing honest perspectives on maturity, life experience, and what she values in romantic partners at different stages of her life. The discussion extends to her lifestyle in Manhattan, where she shares insights about model apartment living and the realities of maintaining that aesthetic and practical lifestyle in one of the world's most expensive cities. Paige reflects on her upbringing at an all-girls school, discussing how this formative experience shaped her views on female friendships and competition among women. She addresses the challenges of dealing with catty and bitchy girls, exploring themes of jealousy, insecurity, and the complexity of female relationships. The conversation also touches on her romantic history, with Paige revealing that she has only been truly in love once, offering a vulnerable perspective on what genuine love means to her. Throughout the episode, the chemistry between Cooper and Paige creates an authentic, unfiltered atmosphere where both guests feel comfortable sharing personal stories and exploring uncomfortable truths about dating, relationships, and growing up in the public eye. The episode captures the essence of a genuine girl talk session, complete with laughter, shocking revelations, and thoughtful reflections on life and love.

Notable Quotes

This one feels like you are sitting around, talking shit with your girlfriends

One of the girl's matched with the other's boyfriend on a dating app

We were dating the same famous actor in NYC at the same exact time, going on the same exact dates

I've only been truly in love once

Dealing with bitchy girls is part of growing up, especially coming from an all-girls school

Products Mentioned